Skip to main content

Birthright Citizenship, Unjust Outcomes, and Why We Need Immigration Reform Now More Than Ever

            Birthright citizenship has long been the norm in the United States and it doesn't look like that will change anytime soon. I for one am glad. As a lawyer I love bright line rules that don’t really require much interpretation. If you’re born here, that’s it…you are a citizen, end of story. That hasn't always been the case in this country and you can read all about it here.

            Most people think this is a pretty fair system, but this arbitrary way that we assign citizenship leads to many unjust outcomes. It is one of the best ways to point out how broken our immigration system really is. Let me be clear…I am not advocating that we abandon birthright citizenship, but I am saying it should be expanded to more people who weren't born in the US. To illustrate my point let me present two fairly common scenarios.

            Scenario 1 – Someone born in the U.S. to non-citizen parents leaves the U.S. with them before age 1. This person grows up outside the U.S. and at age 18 decides, “Hey, I think I might be better off in the U.S., I think I might go live there.” They go to a port of entry with their birth certificate (or easily obtained U.S. passport) and enter the U.S. ready to work, vote, and participate in society without any fear of being deported for a minor offense. This person is also eligible for any means tested public benefit for which he qualifies.

            Scenario 2 – Someone born in a country that does not recognize birthright citizenship to parents who are citizens of a third country. The parents bring this child to the United States before age 1, right around the time the person in scenario one is leaving. This person grows up here, speaks only English, and graduates from high school. Because money was tight for his family and because of our ridiculously arcane immigration laws he never became “legal” (whatever that means). Pay no attention to the fact that his parents are legally present in the U.S. and he has siblings born here. Now he wants to go to college, but he can’t because he can’t afford it. He applies for the means tested benefits that the guy in scenario 1 applies for, but is denied because he lacks legal status. So, not wanting to be a drag on his family or society he enters the workforce. On his way to work one day he is pulled over for an improper turn signal and subsequently arrested for driving while unlicensed. He is turned over to Immigration and Customs Enforcement by local authorities. Because he has no legal status and no way to remain here (again, because of our ridiculous immigration laws) the federal government will try to deport him, not to his country of birth, but to the country of which his parents were previously citizens.

            Now, as for scenario 1…I am totally fine with this. While I have no love for the welfare state, the fact that he can take advantage of it is a problem with the welfare system, NOT the immigration system. I am always in favor of anyone being able to come here anytime and for any reason so long as they can pull their own weight. Arbitrary lines in the sand should not prohibit someone from living where and how they want to live!

            As for scenario 2…there are a few things this guy can do to prevent his deportation. None of them are cheap, guaranteed, or permanent, but why should he have to do anything? Why can’t we have a system that works for people like this? Short answer…politics, and BOTH sides are to blame! Birthright citizenship is a start, but it isn't enough. Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) was something, but it didn't go far enough. Why is someone who is otherwise eligible for DACA, but was 33 the day it was announced not able to benefit like someone who was 29 the day it was announced? Why is someone with a high school diploma more deserving than the kid who decided to work and support his family rather than finish high school? Why is the guy in scenario 1 more deserving than the guy in scenario 2? The answer is NOT to restrict the guy in scenario 1; it’s to expand our conception of citizenship to the guy in scenario 2. Our system is broken…it’s time to fix it.


  1. I agree, and with the ever-increasing diversity of American society, the politicians who continue to hinder immigration reform will one day find themselves (metaphorically speaking) on the outside of the fence, looking in!

    1. Have one daughter born in America (yungest) and two boys not american, one of the receive received his permits through DACA but the other one(oldest) graduated from highshcool with honors didn' t get the approval, he was offered scholsrships to different colleges but alway treated as international student which is 4 times more expensive.
      We came legally to this country 10 years ago and he have an absence of less than two years. I pay taxes every year, personal and business but he doesn't have the right to assist college and pay like his friends so he is just sitting at home waisting a great mind and bright future.
      Nothing worse than feel that you as father are responsable for the frustration, sadness an uncertain future of your son.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

If You Are An Immigrant (even a US Citizen), Here Are 9 Things You Should Know

Are you a Naturalized U.S. Citizen, Lawful Permanent Resident, Visa Holder, or an Undocumented Immigrant? We recommend you take the following steps to protect yourself in our current version of America.
The last couple of weeks have reminded immigrants, even naturalized U.S. citizens, that they were not born in the United States. Our office has received countless phone calls, emails, and social media messages from people worrying about what their family’s future in the United States holds.
Most people want to know what they can do now to protect themselves from what promises to be a wave of anti-immigration activity by the federal government. Trump's Executive Order on Interior Enforcement has some provisions that should make most Americans shiver.  We recommend the following actions for each of the following groups:
Naturalized U.S. citizens. In particular if you have a foreign accent, and you are traveling within 100 miles of any US Border (including the oceans), we strongly rec…

Why is USCIS Taking So Long to Renew DACA Work Permits?

If the calls to our office are any indicator, there are thousands of DACA recipients whose work permit applications were filed at least three months prior to expiration, who are still waiting for their renewed work permits.  Without renewed permits, these individuals lose the right to work legally, the right to drive, and may once again accrue unlawful presence.

The DHS published a notice in October 2014 advising DACA recipients that they could file their request for extension up to 150 days (5 months) prior to expiration.  As with all things government, very few of the DACA recipients, who tend not to frequent government websites, knew about the memo and many did not file so far before expiration perhaps thinking that extending a work permit was a like extending a drivers license, its is done in a few minutes.  As an experienced immigration lawyer will tell you, the USCIS does nothing quickly, and certainly does not worry that a person may lose their job or their driver's licens…


Todas las personas en los Estados Unidos, incluidos los extranjeros y aun los con ordenes de deportacion, tienen ciertos derechos básicos que deben ser respetados por los agentes de Inmigración y Aduanas (ICE). Estos derechos se derivan tanto de la Constitución de los Estados Unidos. y las leyes de Estados Unidos. Como extranjero, usted tiene los siguientes derechos:

Usted tiene el derecho de negar la entrada a un agente de ICE a su casa sin una orden válida. Esta orden debe ser firmado por un juez. Usted puede negarse a abrir la puerta, o se puede cerrar la puerta después de descubrir que el agente no tiene una orden válida. Los agentes del ICE generalmente no vienen con una orden judicial. Estos agentes suelen venir a la casa de alguien con una orden final de deportación, muy temprano en la mañana. Si alguien está golpeando en su puerta a las 6:00 am, no le es requerido abrir la puerta. Mirar fuera de primera. Si es un agente del gobierno, ust…